Understanding the Different Proposals in the Health Care Debate


December 19, 2019

Share This Post

​Key Terms Defined in Health Care Debate 

Of the wealthy, developed nations in the world, the United States alone does not guarantee health care to its people. One in 10 Americans have no health coverage at all, and even for those who do have it, costs for health care are increasing. The United States' health care costs per capita is twice as much as other industrialized countries. Most Americans express support for plans to expand health coverage in public opinion polls. However, the health care debate has become somewhat muddied because the terms used to describe distinct proposals are often used interchangeably.


What is clear is that all of the following expansion proposals will cost the government, and therefore taxpayers, more money. Estimated amounts vary according to the proposal, but a health policy researcher at the University of California, Berkeley estimates that the cost of a universal coverage plan could cost the state of California over $17.3 billion.


The following is an explanation of some of the most common proposals and how they differ.


Public Option


A public option does not get rid of private insurance plans. Instead, it introduces a government-sponsored plan that consumers could purchase in lieu of a private plan. This means that the public option and private plans would be in competition with one another.


Socialized Medicine


Under a system of socialized medicine, the government owns the clinics and hospitals. Doctors and other staff are government employees. One of the most well-known examples of socialized medicine in the world is the National Health Service in the United Kingdom. Contrary to popular belief, however, Canada does not have a system of socialized medicine.


Single-Payer


Instead, Canada is one of many developed countries that uses a single-payer system. In this system, the government does not own the hospitals and clinics, but it does set prices for medical procedures and pays all medical bills.


Universal Coverage


Under a system of universal coverage, everyone would have health insurance. In theory, there are three ways to accomplish this:

  • A private company provides coverage to all Americans
  • The government provides coverage to everyone in the United States
  • The government and one or more private companies work together to provide coverage to all Americans


Medicare Expansion


Medicare is a government program that extends limited health care benefits to all Americans age 65 and older, as well as some younger citizens with disabilities. Several proposals would expand Medicare coverage to include more Americans:


  1. Medicare Buy-In - This proposal would give people not currently eligible for Medicare the option to purchase coverage. Examples may include people who do not receive employer-sponsored insurance or people age 50 to 64.
  2. Medicare for All - This option would enhance Medicare benefits and expand them to the entire U.S. population. Some proposals would eliminate private insurance plans, while others would limit their roles.
  3. Medicare for More - These proposals involve gradual expansion of Medicare. One proposal would make different age groups eligible in a step-by-step process, starting with children. Another would lower the current eligibility age requirement to 50 or 55.


California has taken steps to expand coverage by extending Medicaid to undocumented adults and instituting a statewide individual mandate to subsidize coverage for middle-income earners. For more information about your 
health insurance options, contact us at Sackett & Associates Insurance Services by calling 707-823-3689.


Share This Post

Taking The Pain Out Of Health Insurance

We make it simple to find the right insurance plans for your needs

In just a few quick steps.

Posts You Might Also Like


Small layered cake with candle on a plate by a window, with glasses and a countryside view beyond.
By • November 19, 2026
Facing a Medigap rate increase? Learn how California's birthday rule lets you switch to equal or lesser coverage without health questions. Compare options.
Person reading a letter by a window, with fields visible outside and glasses on the table.
By • November 5, 2026
Got a Medicare Advantage non-renewal notice? Compare your options, learn Medigap guaranteed-issue rights, and get help before Dec 7. Call Sackett.
Two people reviewing documents at a table with pill bottles and a tablet in a warm, sunlit room
By Sackett Insurance Services • October 15, 2026
Helping parents with Medicare during AEP? Learn what to gather, what you can legally do, and when a local broker can support the whole family.
Woman reading a letter at a table by a window overlooking sunlit fields
By Sackett Insurance Services • October 8, 2026
What's new for 2027 Medicare plans? Part D premiums, a $700 deductible, and a $2,400 cap all change. Here's what to check before you renew.
Three people in a meeting room discussing documents around a wooden table.
By Sackett Insurance Services • September 21, 2026
Group health insurance changes confuse employees. Here's a simple open enrollment communication plan every small employer can use.
Man seated at a kitchen table reading a letter beside a cup of coffee, in a warm sunlit room
By Sackett Insurance Services • September 16, 2026
Your Medicare Annual Notice of Change explains what's changing before Annual Enrollment. Here's how to read it and what to flag.